Date: May 04, 2004
The United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit recently held that a "willful" violation is differentiated from lesser violations by an employer's intentional or conscious disregard for an OSHA standard or employee safety. Specifically, the court stated that employers who commit an OSHA violation through negligence have not committed a "willful" violation under the OSH Act. This decision reversed an Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission (OSHRC) decision and held that the Secretary of Labor had not sufficiently established the employer's state of mind, showing that the employer intentionally or consciously violated the loose materials standard when an employee was killed on the worksite. The argument that the employer should have known of the unlawful condition is insufficient in upholding a "willful" violation.To view the full case, go to http://www.ll.georgetown.edu/federal/judicial/dc/opinions/02opinions/02-1379a.pdf.
OSHA cited Weirton Steel Corp. for an alleged willful violation of the Respiratory Protection Standard for allowing employees to work near dangerous levels of carbon monoxide without respiratory protection. Weirton argued that the citation was improper in light of the Air Contaminants Standard, which specifically sets a permissible exposure limit (PEL) of 50 parts per million (ppm) carbon monoxide, based on an eight-hour time weighted average exposure. While OSHA established "ceiling limits" for certain substances, it did not do so for carbon monoxide. Weirton's position was that as long as the company complied with the specific PEL for carbon monoxide, it could not violate the more general Respiratory Protection Standard.The trial court rejected this argument, and the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission (OSHRC) upheld its reasoning. The trial court held that the Air Contaminants Standard did not preempt the Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) Standard. It reasoned that the PPE standard addresses immediate health threats, while the Air Contaminants Standard addresses dangers associated with long-term exposures.To view the full case, go to http://www.oshrc.gov/decisions/pdf_2003/98-0701.pdf.
© 2019 Keller and Heckman LLP. All rights reserved